Is the universal house of justice or the decision making center of Baha’ism infallible?!

Sunday, 11 November 2018 08:38 Written by  font size decrease font size decrease font size increase font size increase font size

Bahaismiran:

The Baha’is consider the universal house of justice foundation infallible; while Shoqi Effendi announced that the members of the universal house of justice may be fallible and said it is up to the guardian of the faith to dismiss the errant members and to counteract their decisions.

     Question: What does this claim mean that the members of the universal house of justice are infallible and their decisions must be performed while it is possible for them to be errant?!

      The Baha’i proselytizers claim for the independent investigation of truth in their faith and imitation has been considered as a foul action!

      Now, the Baha’i proselytizers must be asked: Are Baha’is allowed to oppose and violate against the universal house of justice viewpoint and not to fulfill it having acceptable or unjustifiable reasons? Definitely, the answer is negative. So, the independent investigation of truth is meaningless.

     The other note is that Shoqi Effendi has claimed for the possibility of committing sins by the members of the universal house of justice and their dismissal out of the faith duties. How do Baha’is consider the universal house of justice as infallible based on the Excellency Bahaullah’s statement?! Shoqi Effendi has said: “if a member of the UHJ commits a sin which is harmful for the public, the guardian of the faith will be qualified to dismiss him.”

     The Excellency Bahaullah has also said: “The people’s affairs belong to the universal house of justice men… So, refer them to act based on expediencies. These members are inspired by the divine hidden things. They must be obeyed.[1]

     Therefore, there is a contradiction between Shoqi Effendi and Bahaullah’s statements.

     Most importantly, in current circumstances when there is no guardian of the faith, who is responsible for making decision for the errant members?!!!

 


[1] Hussein Ali Nouri, Ishraqat and some other tablets, the electronic copy, p. 79.

 

Read 896 times
Rate this item
(0 votes)

Template Settings

Color

For each color, the params below will give default values
Black Blue Brow Green Cyan

Body

Background Color
Text Color
Layout Style
Select menu
Google Font
Body Font-size
Body Font-family